[04.12.2024] Other, AnKing Overhaul for Step 1 & 2/AnKingMed, ID 1348421

View Suggestion on AnkiHub

2 Likes

@anking-maintainers could either do this (would also need to remove “why”), or could split this cloze into 2 c1

I do like split cloze. I came up with this to make it a bit more concise.
Sickle cell pain crises can occur as early as {{c1::6 months}} due to increased production of {{c2::defective HbA (e.g. HbF)}}

Then in extra add bit about primary fetal hemoglobin decreasing with age

1 Like

we could do the zanki style

How early can sickle cell pain crises occur, and why do they occur at that time?
{{c1::6 months}}

*Bonus, why does it occur ?

then explain in the extra field

I generally don’t like bonus format because it makes it seem like that information is less important (and the reasoning is arguably more important here)

6 Likes

Would prefer still 1 cloze for whole card to connect it (also, might have just been a mistake, but does not make sense to say “(e.g. HbF)” because the issue is decreased total HbF and increased defective HbA)

3 Likes

prefer original, there’s no rationale given for the change either

1 Like

I like Ian’s version, we can do:

Sickle cell pain crises** can occur as early as {{c1::6 months}} due to increased production of {{c1::defective HbA}} and decreased {{c1::HbF}}

But true there is no rationale, this should’ve been rejected since the question does ask why in the text

2 Likes

Funny enough this is how I originally typed it up in word doc before pasting over in reply. Then changed it last minute to what I sent

It was a mistake/type-o. I originally had what Ahmed replied with but then I tried to condense it more

1 Like

Yeah, I usually I reject immediately if there is no rationale, but this seemed like a good change :grimacing: updated suggestion per discussion

3 Likes

Final decision on card

Like this comment if you are in favor (6 likes we can push) :+1:
Dislike this comment if you disagree (3 dislikes automatically reject) :-1:

@AnKing-Maintainers

GIF by Star Wars

6 Likes