@anking-maintainers Looks like we made the change to add Yersinia back in October last year and may have inadvertently opened the flood gates. Original only included Pasteurella based on the way Sketchy organizes the bugs (Pasteurella is the only one of these in the “Gram neg zoonotics” tag).
I think this would be the last addition to the card… Can’t find any other encapsulated bacteria cross referencing between First Aid’s zoonotic list and AMBOSS bacteria article
support but would suggest changing the lower_yield tag to low_yield for this card given it was originally just 1 bacteria but now changed to 3. Encapsulated is already covered in other cards in the deck for these bacteria (nid:1516056089853, 1510103218988, and 1506284781512), there’s no QID tags, and no step 2 tags
Playing devil’s advocate, why can’t we just add to extra?
This card becomes significantly harder without much benefit?
What if we change this card to ask “Does Pasteurella multocida have a capsule? {{c1::Yes}}” similar to the Salmonella card?
Think that’ll keep this one focused and won’t be double dipping since we have two cards that ask this directly for Salmonella and Yersinia as is. Other card for Pasteurella is slightly different in that it’s asking about which virulence factor is most important
Alternatively, could just delete this note if it doesn’t provide much benefit on top of others in the deck
@herstein.jacob @IantheBFG @Ahmed7 Pulling y’all back in since you already interacted here
Yeah, looking at the Pasteurella Sketchy, they never actually say Pasteurella is the only encapsulated zoonotic bacteria; it’s just the only one in our gram neg zoonotics tag that is encapsulated so whoever made the card made the leap to say that. The card you screenshotted is verbatim all Sketchy has to say about it being encapsulated
Since you said they have individual cards covering each then deleting seems okay, but this card is more getting at the zoonotic part.
Would suggest deleting, it’s just a dupe of multiple cards that individually cover the topic in much detail.
support deleting
I lean towards this viewpoint / would not delete since ard is not just about recalling that these 3 are encapsulated, but specifically that they are transmitted from animal vectors to humans